Just got the new issue of the Atlantic. Howell Raines' attempt at autohagiography in the April issue seems to have triggered some really bizarrely fawning letters:
Congratulations for having the courage to publish Howell Raines's account of his history at the Times. His story had the feeling of a Greek tragedy to me. Like Icarus, he seems to have flown too close to the sun. Much of Raines's story invlved neither money nor violence, but rather, creative passion and ambition. I'm not sure how much the passion for excellence in journalism is valued these days. We have been "spun" so often by public figures, with the willing assent of the commercial media, that it is hard to believe anybody really cares about truth or quality. I'm glad that The Atlantic does, and that Howell Raines does.
Howell Raines's essay was awfully long and densely detailed for breakfast-table reading, but I found it strangely uplifting. I couldn't put it down.
Howell Raines gives us a rare look into the workings of one of democracy's most important institutions. [The press? Or the New York Times--ed]. He underscores the universal need to change while holding on to fundamentals--clearly not an easy task. I, for one, would hate to lose the New York Times, which serves as a baseline for those purporting to reveal the facts and truths in our volatile world. I was left with a sense of the importance of that paper, of the difficulty of the work in progress at the Times, and of the need for courageous journalists like Raines.
Howell Raines really cares about truth? Um, didn't he get in trouble because his paper was printing stories that were outright fabrications when they weren't simply misleading? One hopes the letters editor at the Atlantic thought this letter was deliciously, if unintentionally, ironic--especially since the comparison of Raines to the vain, self-willed, and ultimately self-destructing Icarus.
One hopes.
Posted by: eLizabeth bennett on June 8, 2004 12:04 PMMy message to Howard would be:
Howard, what universe do you think you are living in?!?
I wonder if any of those commenting about poor
Howell Raines actually READ the New York Times.
I do - because it has simply the very best
Sports Writing in the US of A.
The rest of the paper is best used for lining
the bird cage. Fred - the Parakeet - seems to
like it best when we keep the editorial pages
on top :-}
"autohagiography" is a word I have only seen one before, by Aleister Crowley. Is there some subtle point here I am missing? (That Raines is an idiot is certainly not at issue.)
Posted by: Oscar on June 9, 2004 05:48 PMComments are Closed.