December 11, 2005

silhouette3.JPG From the desk of Jane Galt:

Shameless Begging: Book edition

Some of y'all have emailed me to ask for recommendations for books to read and DVDs to watch, to go with the recommendations for kitchen gear and home electronics I offered earlier. Here are the book recommendations; DVDs will hopefully come later, but I'm sick as a dog, so I make no promises.

As you may know, now is the time of year when I engage in an absolutely shameless attempt to encourage you to earn me money from my Amazon.com associates account, under the thin pretense of suggesting things you can buy your loved ones for Christmas. I am poor, and my student loan officer is hungry, and the people at the workhouse will only give me one serving of gruel a day. . . this brazen commercialization of The Birth of Our Lord is the only way that I can afford to buy myself the books with which I enrich my mind so that I can offer you keen insight and witty commentary on a quasi-daily basis.

If you're going to do your Christmas shopping on Amazon this year, just click the handy links provided by me or another of your favourite bloggers (mine's over there at the right, if you scroll down a little!), and at absolutely not cost to yourself, you can send a little commission our way. We get the commission even if you buy something other than the product we linked, though the commission is higher for direct links.

However, even if you don't order through Amazon, all the stuff I'll suggest here is stuff that I genuinely love, so do consider purchasing for yourself or your loved ones offline. And if you do buy something I recommend, please, please, please email me to let me know how it went over.

And if you don't like anything you see here, please feel free to peruse last year's selections, though there is some overlap.

Fiction

Anna Karenina Yes, I know, it's shameful, but I just got around to reading it this year. Outstanding, even in translation . . . and I generally hate translation. Tolstoy's characters breathe even though they (never) lived over 100 years ago.

Letters from Earth This is a collection of Mark Twain's unpublished writings, which was put together after his death. It lacks the polish of his published work, and some of it is unfinished, but it offers in some ways a more intimate look into his mind. Especially recommend it paired with The Autobiography of Mark Twain, which is a sampling of the autobiographical musings he dictated at the end of his life. Because he didn't mean it to be published until after his death, it is much more frank than most autobiography, and of course, Mark Twain is one of the most brilliant writers ever.

A Game of Thrones, A Clash of Kings, and a Storm of Swords by George R. R. Martin, as discussed in this post I can't tell you how much I enjoyed these books . . . they really made time fly in London

The Man in the Gray Flannel Suit It's a period piece--postwar 1950's "Isn't there something better than this?" literature. He doesn't do it as well as John Cheever, but that's hardly a put-down, since Cheever was one of the prose greats of the twentieth century (and if you don't own The Stories of John Cheever, then run, don't walk, down to your nearest bookstore and pick one up.) Nonetheless, it's enjoyable not merely as a period piece--though peaking into the heads of our near ancestors is in itself a pleasurable reading experience--but as a novel, even though it gets a little sappy at the end.


Past Due by William Lashner. As you can see, my reading is eclectic; I whipsaw between genre fiction and "classic literature". But only selected genre literature. William Lashner is one of the few mystery writers who made my cut. It's sort of noirish fiction set in modern-day Philadelphia, narrated by a wanna-be mob lawyer. He's no Tolstoy, but he will help you pass more than a few pleasant hours. I liked his earlier books--Hostile Witness, Bitter Truth, and Fatal Flaw even better, but I recommend them all very highly if you like mysteries.

The Stepford Wives Didn't know it was a book, did you? I confess, I was taken aback by how much I enjoyed this book, which has a lean, understated prose style that really sets off the underlying horror. I liked it so much that I bought Rosemary's Baby, which I also highly recommend.

Heart of Darkness I reread it while I was in London, and may nominate the beginning of this book for best prose ever. I actually get chills down my spine every time I read the words "And this too was among the dark places of the earth". If you haven't read this, you must, and not just because you liked Apocalypse Now.

Non-Fiction

Freakonomics Yes, you've heard about it from every economics blog in creation, including theirs. But it really is enjoyable. It won't give you a basic grounding in economics, but it will give you insight into economic problem-solving. It's just a bonus that the writing is engaging and entertaining.

In the Wake of Madness It's a popular history about a whaling boat where a couple members of the crew kill the captain. The author dissects the official story, which had native crewmen going bonkers for no particular reason, and reveals that the captain was possibly crazy, certainly cruel. I know you probably weren't expecting me to recommend a book on whaling, but I found it surprisingly engrossing. I also learned a great deal about whaling, not that I expect this to come in handy any time soon.

Where are the customer's yachts? This is a humorous book about Wall Street written in mid-century, skewering the conceits of both investors and brokers. The shocking thing is that almost all of it still applies today.

Against Depression The author of Listening to Prozac, which I read when it came out, followed up with this book, which argues against the notion that one's depressed self is somehow the authentic, natural self, and that medication is thus false comfort. He also fights those who point out that since great artists tend to be disproportionately depressed, there is danger in treating all depression, saying that we would not have left Van Gogh untreated if he'd had cancer, and depression is little different. I'm not sure I agree with this--it seems to me that depression, with its sharper insight, does spur art, and I think that there are things in life more important than being happy--at least on even-numbered days. Anyway, even if you disagree with this, it's very much worth reading if you're interested in happiness research.

The Lessons of History by Will & Ariel Durant. The story of the Durants is lurid enough to justify reading their work just for the prurient interest: Will fell in love with Ariel while he was teaching her at the Ferrer School, an early experimental school. She was just fourteen when he resigned his post and married her. Later they collaborated on the enormous multi-volume Story of Civilization, which I'll read someday when I have a zillion dollars to spare. This book isn't so ambitious; it's just a summing up of what they've learned about people and governments from their study of history. And it turns out the prurient interest is just gravy; their work is delightful. I can't recommend it highly enough.

Into the Wild I first read Jon Krakauer because he was on Everest in 1996 when everything went to hell; his chronicle of that expedition, Into Thin Air, is brilliant. Into the Wild is less biographical, more journalistic; it's a reconstruction of a boy on the hippy fringe who breaks all ties with his family and goes off into the Alaska wilderness to test his manhood, where he dies. It all sounds rather juvenile and melodramatic, and it is, but at the heart of juvenile melodrama there is a worthy core of aspiration that Krakauer deftly extracts.

More later, if and when I think of them. For now, I'm off to bed with a Nyquil.


Posted by Jane Galt at December 11, 2005 08:39 PM | TrackBack | Technorati inbound links
Comments

You linked to the audio version of the Durant book. Will you still get credit if I buy the dead trees version?

Posted by: bobby on December 11, 2005 11:06 PM

Jane,

Steven Pressfield, "Gates of Fire"

You absolutely have to read it, even if I have to buy it for you.

Marcus

Posted by: marcus on December 11, 2005 11:36 PM

bobby: Based on my experience elsewhere (albeit starting out with a searchbox), the answer is "probably". I searched for X, and bought X and Y, and the referrer got credit for both.

Posted by: Nathan Sharfi on December 12, 2005 12:54 AM

The story of the Durants is lurid enough to justify reading their work just for the prurient interest: Will fell in love with Ariel while he was teaching her at the Ferrer School, an early experimental school. She was just fourteen when he resigned his post and married her.

Of course, in 1913, marrying at age 14 was "a little young" rather than "robbing the cradle." 16 was still a common courting age for women, and much past 18 was Spinsterville Central. And unless you had a whopper of an inheritance coming your direction or could live with the family of a sibling, that wasn't good news; the job market for older women, outside of homemaking and family agriculture, was a tad thin.

Posted by: anony-mouse on December 12, 2005 03:12 AM

I read Gates of Fire, and agree with your assessment. But I didn't read it this year, so I left it off the list. Still, I highly recommend it to any readers.

Anony-mouse--It wasn't quite as scandalous as it would be today--i.e. they didn't put him in jail--but it was still quite a scandal. He lost his job, and it dogged him for quite some time.

Posted by: Jane Galt on December 12, 2005 07:36 AM

The Story of Civilization is worth the effort. Just give yourself time.

Posted by: Randy on December 12, 2005 09:38 AM

A commeont on the depression book (without having read it). Seems like it would be pretty easy to ask the depressed people whether or not they wanted to be depressed. If they dno't, and there is a way to help them, then forcing them to remain depressed is pretty evil.

Not that depression is readily treated by medications. True depression is about as well treated by therapy as drugs. Other issues like anxiety, ADD, psychoses, etc... are more treatable by medications.

Again, the whole debate should really revolve around the desires and interests of the patient, IMHO.

Posted by: Earnest Iconoclast on December 12, 2005 10:00 AM

I'd recommend Sloan Wilson's autobiography, rather than his novel:

' What shall we wear to this party?: The man in the gray flannel suit twenty years before & after'

Posted by: Patrick R. Sullivan on December 12, 2005 01:00 PM

As far as History Books go - I would add on The Guns of August by Barbara Tuchman

Story of the first month of WWI - fairly interesting stuff there...

Posted by: Michael in CO on December 12, 2005 02:08 PM

I would balance Into The Wild by suggesting Between A Rock And A Hard Place by Aron Ralston. Another young man who tested his manhood by going into the wilderness, only he passed the final exam.

Posted by: triticale on December 12, 2005 02:38 PM

Cheever should also be read because it is a huge Seinfeld reference

Posted by: Fenton on December 12, 2005 02:40 PM

"Seems like it would be pretty easy to ask the depressed people whether or not they wanted to be depressed." Back when I was severely depressed, I think I would have answered with something like, "Why bother, it's not going to work."

Posted by: markm on December 12, 2005 05:27 PM

Speaking of Cheever references in Seinfeld: I tried to read Falconer after it was mentioned in the show (George was reading it) and only made it half way through; too damn depressing. I do like his short stories, however.

Posted by: hank p on December 12, 2005 05:33 PM

but it was still quite a scandal. He lost his job

Officially he resigned, but yeah, I get the picture. I suppose the man should have gone to France for the vows and consumation, eh?

Posted by: anony-mouse on December 12, 2005 07:05 PM

For anyone who tried Tolstoy or Dostoevsky in the past and couldn't deal with with the language, I strongly recommend the new Pevear/Volokhonsky translations.

I didn't realize how much of a difference translations really made till I started rereading the classics. I absolutely LOATHE the classic Constance Garnett renditions of the famous Russians. I never even finished many of the classic Russian novels I started. Now I find myself swimming with delight in the ocean of great Russian literature. But the way to get there is to read the best modern translations.

Anna Karenina and Dostoevsky's the Idiot are absolutely transformed in the Pevear/Volokhonsky versions. Short of learning Russian this is as good as it gets.

Posted by: anon on December 13, 2005 09:27 AM

Pevear and Volokhonsky are currently working on a War and Peace translation. Should be fantastic!

Posted by: A Reader on December 13, 2005 12:57 PM

Now this guy, on the other hand, has discovered that 14 in the present day IS a recipe for legal trouble.

Posted by: anony-mouse on December 13, 2005 02:50 PM

Two things: First, Against Depression explores a more complicated, interesting thesis than this blurb (which shows a cursory reading) suggests. Second, anybody who thinks that happiness is the opposite of depression needs to read more than Kramer's book (which I also recommend) to get the big picture.

Posted by: Felicia on December 14, 2005 07:26 AM

Comments are Closed.